Eagles – One Of These Nights (1975)
This week on Your Dad’s Car Stereo, we’re covering the album the brought Eagles into the forefront of the 1970s rock scene and solidified their place on Classic Rock stations for decades. Formed in California in 1971, the quintet of Don Felder, Glenn Frey, Don Henley, Bernie Leadon, and Randy Meisner, were known as Eagles until Leadon was replaced by Joe Walsh. Despite releasing albums that churned out popular singles like Take It Easy, Witchy Woman, Peaceful Easy Feeling, and Desperado, it was this album, spawning three singles that launched them into the spotlight. You could say that it was this album where the Eagles really “took flight!”
One Of These Nights is, on the whole, an album about relationships. It features Hollywood Waltz, a song about loving and respecting your partner, but on the obverse side of the coin is Lyin’ Eyes, a song about cheating in relationships. The lead single, One Of These Nights, is about the darker aspects of humanity and expresses that there’s no need to hide that in a relationship and that there’s always someone out there like you. The album features a uniquely Eagles sound that is dominated by a country rock sound and borrows heavily from traditional cowboy/western ballads, particularly on songs like Too Many Hands and Visions.
Dad’s Thoughts- The Breakdown
One Of These Nights: This is one of the best songs put to vinyl. Period. Ever. The smooth rock track opens with haunting guitar before diving into a well-polished, grooving verse and features classic Eagles vocal harmonies in the chorus. Seriously, listen to this song if you’ve never heard it before, this is one of my all-time favorites, and for that it receives the first “They don’t make music like this anymore Award” for this series. Dad’s Rating: 10/10
Too Many Hands: Eagles followed one of the strongest singles they ever released with a slightly above average track. Certainly not a bad song but it just doesn’t hold a candle to the song that came before. I actually get a feeling that there was a cowboy/western United States influence on the music in this song that you can hear in the guitar riff at the end of each sentence in the chorus. Yee-haw! Dad’s Rating: 7/10
Hollywood Waltz: This song puts me to sleep. I had to listen to it a few times before I get a message out of the lyrics, and I actually found that I enjoy the message of learning to love someone. The cowboy ballad influence is strong in this one. Despite this, it still puts me to…ZzzzzzzzzzZZZZZzzzzzZZzzzz Dad’s Rating: 6/10
Journey Of The Sorcerer: A song for a full orchestra and a BANJO!! This was the soundtrack for Douglas Adams’ Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy to boot! I’m not sure who thought that a banjo would amplify an epic song appropriate for travelling across the universe, but thank goodness they did. Give this song a shot, it’s a little odd if you’re not familiar with Douglas Adams’ original radio show or the remade movie in the early aughts, but it’s a “journey” worth taking. Dad’s Rating: 8/10
Lyin’ Eyes: This was one of the lead singles off of One Of These Nights, and the soft rock/cowboy ballad is felt as much here as it is on Hollywood Waltz. This song is more palletable than the former for two reasons: 1. Classic Eagles vocal harmony is present that was sorely lacking on the earlier track and 2. The tempo doesn’t put you to sleep. I’d be lyin’ if I told you any different! Dad’s Rating: 7/10
Take It To The Limit: So this is a staple of classic rock radio to this day, and that makes sense considering it was the third single off of the album. This song deserves a sing-a-long every time it comes on, and it’s just a fantastic ballad that’s easy to listen to. The multiple building refrains at the end are one of my favorite parts. If you’ve never sat and listened to this then I can only recommend doing so. This song doesn’t just take the album to the limit of excellence, it pushes it over that limit and helped cement it in rock history. Dad’s Rating: 8/10
Visions: This song actually surprised me because I had never listened to it before. Going in having never listened to it, it has come out as one of my favorites off the album. Visions is a classic 1970s southern rock song done right. It’s got a very Lynyrd Skynyrd feel to it. If you have even a passing interest in Skynyrd or CCR, this song will tickle the auricular orifices. Dad’s Rating: 8/10
After The Thrill Is Gone: Snooze. I know this is one of Eagles’ more popular songs, but skip it, particularly if you sat through Hollywood Waltz. Dad’s Rating: 5/10
I Wish You Peace: This is an interesting track to close off the album. I Wish You Peace is easily my least favorite song on the album and it sparked controversy within the band when it was recorded. Don Henley has spoken out against it, stating that it was only on the album at the request of Bernie Leadon and his girlfriend Patti Davis. It’s definitely an outlier on this album, and an outlier worth skipping. I hope this song can find peace with itself, considering no one listens to it. Dad’s Rating 4/10 The opinion above is protected under the Fair Use provision of United States Copyright Law, 17 U.S.C §107 which allows for the fair use of a copyrighted work for criticism without infringement on the copyright.